Holdawayite is a very rare manganese carbonate hydroxide mineral typically found in the famous zinc mines of Franklin and Sterling Hill, New Jersey. It generally occurs as delicate, pale pink platy crystals or granular masses embedded within larger manganese-zinc mineral assemblages. Collectors prize it for its unique chemistry and extreme scarcity in the global mineral market.

Hardness
3-4
Mohs
Luster
Vitreous
Streak
White
Transparency
Transparent

Is this holdawayite?

5-step field check

Run through these checks against the specimen in your hand. The more boxes tick, the more confident the ID.

  • 1
    Test the hardness
    Try to scratch holdawayite with a known reference. Holdawayite sits at Mohs 3-4 — softer than the next harder reference, harder than the previous one.
  • 2
    Check the streak
    Drag the specimen across an unglazed porcelain plate. Holdawayite leaves a white streak.
  • 3
    Read the luster
    Hold the specimen under a strong light. Holdawayite typically shows a vitreous luster.
  • 4
    Match the color range
    Compare against the expected color range: pink, pale pink, colorless.
  • 5
    Look at form & habit
    Crystal system: monoclinic. Typical habit: platy crystals, granular aggregates.

Often confused with

Holdawayite vs. its common look-alikes — and how to tell them apart in the field.

Often found alongside holdawayite

Minerals reported to co-occur with holdawayite. Spotting these in float or country rock is a strong cue you are in the right ground.

All properties

Chemical formula
Mn₆(CO₃)₂(OH,Cl)₈
Mohs hardness
3-4
Density
3.32 g/cm³
Streak
White
Luster
Vitreous
Transparency
Transparent
Crystal system
Monoclinic
Crystal habit
Platy Crystals, Granular Aggregates
Cleavage
Perfect On {001}
Rarity
Rare
Uses
Collector
Host rock
Metamorphosed Zinc-manganese Ore Bodies
Typical price
$50-300 per specimen

Where rockhounds find holdawayite

Classic worldwide localities

  • Franklin, New Jersey, USA
  • Sterling Hill, New Jersey, USA

Field-hunting tip

Look in metamorphosed zinc-manganese ore bodies country — that is the host setting where holdawayite typically forms. If you start seeing hodgkinsonite, willemite, franklinite in float, you are in the right ground. Field specimens usually show a platy crystals, granular aggregates habit, so train your eye for that shape before scanning the outcrop.

Common questions

How do you identify holdawayite?+
Mohs hardness is 3-4. It typically shows a vitreous luster. The streak is white. Common colors include pink, pale pink, colorless.
Where is holdawayite found?+
Notable localities include Franklin, New Jersey, USA; Sterling Hill, New Jersey, USA.
How much is holdawayite worth?+
Typical asking prices fall in the range of $50-300 per specimen. Quality, size, and provenance can move individual specimens well outside that range.
What rocks look like holdawayite?+
Holdawayite is most often confused with Calcite, Rhodochrosite. A quick hardness test and a streak check separate the look-alikes faster than color alone.
What minerals are found with holdawayite?+
Holdawayite commonly co-occurs with Hodgkinsonite, Willemite, Franklinite, Zincite. Spotting any of these in float or country rock is a useful trip signal.
What kind of rock does holdawayite form in?+
Holdawayite typically forms in metamorphosed zinc-manganese ore bodies. Working float back to the host body is the standard way to chase a fresh occurrence.
What is holdawayite used for?+
Holdawayite is used in collector.

Find holdawayite on the map

RockHoundR shows mapped rockhounding spots, access rules, and lets you log every find.

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play